What is the success rate of data recovery?
Our founder and lead technician, Joseph Montanti, handles cases personally.
There's no single success rate for data recovery because your chances depend on which parts are damaged and how badly. Some faults rule out recovery. Once we've diagnosed your device, we can tell you the odds of getting your files back.
On this page
The jobs behind an advertised rate
A lab that advertises one figure, say 97 percent, can't apply that number to every device. If it takes only hard drives with bad sectors, it can quote a high rate just by picking the easier jobs. Give that same lab the drives other shops have already tried to recover, and its rate can drop even if the technicians do the work just as well.
What we can read from a scratched hard drive
A hard drive's heads read your files from the surfaces of the platters. We regularly work on drives with platter damage. We get files back less often from those drives than from ones that come in unopened with failed read heads and no clicking. If the platters are too badly scratched, we can't get the files back.
On a hard drive that clicked after a fall, the damage reached the place where the drive kept its own start-up files. It spun up with replacement heads but reported zero capacity. We couldn't repair those start-up files, so the photos stayed out of reach.
We could still read the undamaged surfaces of a dropped drive with a scratched platter. The scratched surface held the map the drive used to keep those files organized. We got photos and videos back sorted by type, without their original folders. That was a partial recovery.
The chips we need in phones, iPods, SD cards and MacBooks
If a phone's processor or its NAND storage chip is cracked, we can't recover the files. Damage to the EEPROM also rules out recovery.
We tested the storage from a phone that died overnight and found it healthy. We cleared the electrical shorts and moved the phone's processor, RAM, storage and another original chip to a donor board. The phone still wouldn't start. We concluded its processor had failed, and we couldn't recover the photos.
On an iPod 5 that wouldn't power on, a partial short cleared only when we removed the processor. We couldn't get the pictures back because the iPod needed its failed processor to decrypt them.
If an SD card has snapped in half through the NAND, we can't recover the files. We also can't recover cards whose controller uses LDPC error correction.
On a MacBook with an M-series chip, the internal storage is encrypted by default and the key that unlocks it is protected inside the Apple chip. If the processor dies or the NAND chips die, we can't recover the files.
What a diagnosis tells you about your device
We examine your device to find out which parts failed and which ones we can still use to reach your files. We can then tell you your chances before you decide whether to approve recovery work.
The $100 diagnostic is non-refundable once diagnostics start, and donor drives or replacement parts you approve are non-refundable once ordered, even if recovery fails. We credit the diagnostic fee toward the recovery cost on success.
Questions to ask a lab before you send your device
- Will you tell me my chances after diagnosis, before I approve the recovery work?
- What will I owe if you can't recover my files?
- If you get files back without their original folders, how do you count that result?
- Do you take devices another lab has already opened?
Questions about hard drive recovery
Can you work on a drive another lab has already tried?
Yes. Other labs had already tried the drive that gave us photos and videos without their folders. We cut off its damaged head so the remaining heads could read the good surfaces.
Why couldn't you repair the start-up files on the drive that reported zero capacity?
We rebuilt one start-up file from its two damaged copies. Platter damage kept us from writing it back where the drive needed it, so the repair failed.
Get help with data recovery
Bring your device to our Lincroft lab during opening hours, or mail it in.
How to mail your deviceThe $100 diagnostic is non-refundable once diagnostics start, and donor drives or replacement parts you approve are non-refundable once ordered, even if recovery fails.
Published by MDrepairs
MDrepairs is a data recovery and electronics repair lab in Lincroft, New Jersey. Our founder and lead technician Joseph Montanti films real cases for our YouTube channel, showing tools, repair steps and recovery outcomes.